The Power of (Not) Listening

“Black women are 243 percent more likely to die from pregnancy- or childbirth-related causes.”—Nothing Protects Black Women from Dying in Pregnancy and Childbirth: Not education. Not income. Not even being an expert on racial disparities in health care. (ProPublica and NPR News, December 2017)

“Black infants in America are now more than twice as likely to die as white infants.”—Why America’s Black Mothers and Babies Are in a Life-or-Death Crisis (The New York Times Magazine, April 2018)

 

As a consultant for a social impact firm, specifically focused on health disparities and closing gaps in care, I’ve become accustomed and even desensitized to headlines and statistics like the ones above.

But as a young Black woman looking to start a family of my own, these headlines and stats are much more personal, alarming, and terrifying.

I remember the moment that my mindset switched from, “Oh another crisis disproportionately affecting my people” to “Oh no. This affects ME. Right now!” An old colleague from CDC shared the Pro Publica/NPR article about Shalon Irvin. The title of the article, “Nothing Protects Black Women from Dying in Pregnancy and Childbirth” – and my friend’s words about her colleague – compelled me to read the full 3,000+ word piece. Less than half-way through the article, a steady stream of tears started rolling down my face.

Shalon was educated and motivated. I’m educated and motivated. Shalon was economically stable. I’m economically stable. Shalon even worked to understand and prevent health disparities, just like I do. By the time I got to the part of the article with the hard data — that in New York City, where I live, Black mothers are 12 times more likely to die than white mothers — I had to take a break to pull myself together.

The message was clear to me. Shalon did everything “right.” She understood her risks and advocated for herself with her doctors. But it still wasn’t enough. In fact, the thread that permeates not only Shalon’s story, but the countless other stories like hers (including tennis superstar Serena Williams) is the complete disregard for the urgency of listening. Taking women seriously, hearing their voices, and paying attention to what they say (and don’t say). These women tried to advocate for themselves. They knew something was wrong. But their doctors didn’t listen.

Steeped in a history of unethical mistreatment of Black women for the sake of “medicine,” healthcare providers often believe the myth that Black women have higher pain tolerance, are difficult, uneducated, complain too much, etc. These myths, whether conscious or unconscious, have led to a systemic pattern of ignoring the voices of Black women which has in turn seriously compromised our health and endangered our lives.

It’s a theme I’ve seen time and time again over the last 10 years in my work addressing the HIV epidemic: Black and Brown people feel unheard, undervalued, and invisible. As a result, they’re suffering and dying at disproportionate rates.

I’m lucky enough to work for a company that values listening to the people and communities that we work in. Deep community and stakeholder engagement are pillars of the programs we run, particularly in my work addressing HIV/AIDS issues. Still I can’t help but ask myself what more I — and we — can be doing professionally to continue shining a light on the issues around Black women and maternal health and advocating for systemic change. I’m not sure. But politicians, coalitions, and organizations have taken notice of the recent media attention around the issue and seem committed to making change happen.

Senator Kamala Harris (along with 13 of her Democratic colleagues) recently introduced the Maternal Care Access and Reducing Emergencies (CARE) Act to directly address persistent implicit bias that affects Black women before, during, and after childbirth. The State of New York has responded by establishing a task force on maternal mortality and disparate racial outcomes. The task force is meant to lead a state-sponsored initiative that will include efforts to review and better address maternal death and morbidity, with a focus on racial disparities,. The task force will also work to expand community outreach and take new actions to increase access to prenatal and perinatal care, including establishing a pilot expansion of Medicaid coverage for doulas.

A wealth of research shows that engaging a Doula and midwife significantly improves health outcomes for moms and babies. Yet Doulas and midwives are a luxury that a lot of families – especially Black and Brown families – aren’t aware of or can’t afford. Ancient Song Doula Services in my home city of Brooklyn, NY, is working to combat that. The Family Health and Birth Center in Washington, DC, offers a model of prenatal care and education that significantly improves the health and wellness of Black women and children. These types of local models keep community and the voices of women at the center of their work. Leaders of these organizations should be at the decision-making table to help scale the larger state and city-wide responses.  

While this issue is decades in the making, the sudden urgency around it speaks to the power of the media as a conduit of change. As I reflected on my own experiences and the experiences of the women in my family, it dawned on me that my own mother and one of my sisters also had traumatic and near-fatal experiences during and after childbirth. It was only after this recent media frenzy that I felt the true weight of those experiences and connected them to the crisis. It took articles like Shalon’s story and the Lost Mothers series on NPR to adequately amplify the voices of these women. As a communication professional, this is a reminder to me how important it is to not only listen, but to be active and outspoken, and to amplify.

I believe that we’re at a tipping point in this crisis. Mass media attention means more awareness, and that’s the first step in trying to solve any epidemic or social problem. I have hope that through the power of listening, my colleagues in public health, racial justice, and social impact can work together toward a change over time. Initiatives like the California Maternal Quality Care Collaborative have worked toward changing maternal mortality rates for the last 10 years, and they have slowly but surely achieved rates that are 30% lower than the national average. Until change like that happens nationwide, and benefits all women, I will remain committed to intentionally listening in my work. And on a personal level, I will remember the lessons from these women’s stories and never stop fighting to be heard.

How Companies Meet Stakeholder Expectations

 “A story is based on what people think is important, so when we live a story, we are telling people around us what we think is important.”  Donald Miller, CEO, StoryBrand

Companies today are more engaged with and active in society and their communities than ever before, but they have not gained the recognition or trusted relationships they seek from consumers and the general public.

Why? Continue reading

Three Essential Elements for Evaluating Systems Initiatives

You may be hearing terms like systems change, collective impact, and multi-sectoral initiatives a lot these days to describe situations where multiple actors are working together to tackle complex social problems. If you’re working or considering working within one of these types of initiatives, it’s critical to first recognize the complexity of the system (or set of interconnected parts) you’re working with and to think about what success would look like within that system. Although systems are complex, systems thinking – and the corresponding evaluation design – can be broken down into three essential elements [1]: Continue reading

The First Year of a New Presidency Moves Philanthropy to Action

The speculation for most of us began on Wednesday morning, November 9, 2016.

Regardless of political affiliation, the election win by a presidential candidate who promised dramatic changes in governing style and policies from the prior administration meant that grantmakers might have to rethink their current strategies and, quite possibly, fundamental priorities. As the new administration’s policy agenda rolled out over its first year in office, the interest areas of more and more funders were touched by the shifting political landscape. Continue reading

Think Local: Local Consultants are an Untapped Resource for “Sticky” Capacity Building Investments

At TCC Group, we work closely with our clients and partners to emphasize the essential nature of collaboration in capacity building and nonprofit effectiveness. Capacity building investments can only “stick” when the ability to collaborate is elevated in any organizational change effort. A collaborative approach to capacity building provides support well beyond funding, while establishing vital relationships that will serve those involved long past the life of a capacity building grant.

For years, many in the nonprofit realm have advocated for increases in unrestricted funding, general operating support, and/or dedicated capacity building funds. But when it comes to reaping the full benefits of capacity building dollars, funding is not always enough. Continue reading

How Do We Evaluate Progress Towards the Sustainable Development Goals?

What can we do to effectively evaluate progress towards the global Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs)? This was one of the principal questions asked at the recent conference hosted in Guanajuato, Mexico by three international evaluation associations: the International Development Evaluation Association (IDEAS), the Latin American and Caribbean Monitoring, Evaluation, and Systematization Network (ReLAC), and the Latin American and Caribbean Monitoring and Evaluation Network (REDLACME).

Throughout the three-day conference, which brought together approximately 500 evaluators and evaluation commissioners from 47 different countries, I gathered seven recurring themes posed as answers to this one question. Continue reading

Best Practices in Corporate Citizenship Structures

Companies with strong reputations as corporate citizens are respected for providing value to society in a comprehensive way – through their products and services, their operational excellence, and their support of the community.

As companies face increasing pressure from stakeholders to address complex societal issues, many are developing programs and initiatives with ambitious social impact goals, but often, without the requisite structure to ensure the programs are effective. Continue reading

Be Informed: Developing Content for Media Campaigns

Media campaigns are intended to affect their audiences – such as convincing people not to text and drive, or persuading people to purchase a product or vote for a particular candidate. There are various touchpoints where media can help lead an audience from awareness to action on an issue. Being able to track these touchpoints – and the audiences engaged – enables organizations and media distributors to more efficiently and effectively test their content as well as intelligently move audiences from awareness to action at a faster, more effective rate. Continue reading

Three Ways Foundations Can Navigate Changing Political Tides

Is it on? Is it off? Is it on? Is it off? Our heads are spinning with the series of attempts to repeal the Affordable Care Act (ACA), and the numerous ways in which both the federal government and state level actors are strategizing to alter and/or erode health policy. In today’s turbulent climate, when shifting political winds and policy changes go hand-in-hand with ever-expanding health care needs across the country, how can health funders be strategically effective?

TCC’s Melinda Fine Ed.D. and Jessica Mowles share three strategic learning processes that will engage foundations and funders during complex times.

Read “Three Ways Foundations Can Navigate Changing Political Tides” on gih.org >